From FIR to Supreme Court: A Practical Criminal Litigation Manual for Advocates
FROM
FIR TO SUPREME COURT
A Practical Criminal Litigation Manual for an Advocate
Blog by:
Jayprakash B. Somani,
Advocate, Supreme Court of India,
Cell: PA 9322188701
www.jayprakashsomani.com
www.supremecourtlawfirm.com
Part 1
I.
THE COMPLETE CRIMINAL CASE FLOW
The usual journey is:
Information/Complaint
?
FIR – Police Station
?
Investigation
?
Arrest / Notice / Search / Seizure / Remand
?
Bail / Anticipatory Bail / Default Bail
?
Police Report / Charge-sheet / Closure Report
?
Cognizance by Magistrate
?
Supply of documents
?
Discharge / Framing of Charge
?
Trial
?
Evidence of Prosecution
?
Cross-examination
?
Statement of Accused
?
Defence Evidence
?
Final Arguments
?
Judgment – Conviction / Acquittal
?
Appeal / Revision
?
High Court
?
Supreme Court – SLP / Criminal Appeal
?
Review
?
Curative Petition
This entire structure must now be read with BNS,
BNSS and BSA, which came into force on 1 July 2024.
II.
FIRST QUESTION: WHICH CRIMINAL CODE APPLIES?
This should be checked before drafting anything.
Old regime
|
Subject |
Old statute |
|
Offences |
IPC, 1860 |
|
Procedure |
CrPC, 1973 |
|
Evidence |
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 |
New regime
|
Subject |
New statute |
|
Offences |
BNS, 2023 |
|
Procedure |
BNSS, 2023 |
|
Evidence |
BSA, 2023 |
For example:
|
Old IPC |
New BNS |
|
302 – Murder |
103(1) |
|
304 – Culpable homicide |
105 |
|
304A – Death by negligence |
106(1) |
|
306 – Abetment of suicide |
108 |
|
307 – Attempt to murder |
109 |
|
304B – Dowry death |
80 |
|
376 – Rape |
64 |
|
376D – Gang rape |
70(1) |
|
498A – Cruelty |
85 |
|
406 – Criminal breach of trust |
316 |
|
420 – Cheating/delivery of property |
318(4) |
|
463/465 – Forgery |
335/336, depending on offence |
|
379 – Theft |
303 |
The official
BPR&D comparative material confirms, for example, IPC 302 ? BNS 103(1), IPC
304A ? BNS 106(1), and IPC 307 ? BNS 109.
Practice point: Never mechanically substitute
numbers. BNS has merged, split and modified several IPC provisions.
Always read the actual ingredients and punishment in the applicable statute.
III.
STAGE 1 — INFORMATION BEFORE FIR
A. Cognizable offence
Old:
Section 154 CrPC
New:
Section 173 BNSS
Section 173 BNSS corresponds to Section 154 CrPC.
The governing principle remains:
If information discloses a cognizable offence,
registration of FIR is ordinarily mandatory.
Leading case
Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh, (2014)
2 SCC 1
Constitution Bench.
The Supreme Court held that registration of FIR is
mandatory when information discloses commission of a cognizable offence,
subject to the recognised categories where a limited preliminary inquiry may be
undertaken.
The Supreme Court continues to treat Lalita Kumari
as the controlling authority on this proposition, including under the
corresponding Section 173 BNSS.
IV.
IF POLICE REFUSES TO REGISTER FIR
Under the old regime:
Section 154(3) CrPC
Approach:
Superintendent of Police
Then:
Section 156(3) CrPC
Application before Magistrate.
Under BNSS:
Section 173 BNSS
and
Section 175(3) BNSS
Section 175(3) corresponds to old Section 156(3).
Important Supreme Court authorities
1. Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P.
(2008) 2 SCC 409
Important principle:
The Magistrate has wide power to ensure proper
investigation and is not required to leave the complainant remediless when
police fail to perform statutory duties.
2. Priyanka Srivastava v. State of U.P.
(2015) 6 SCC 287
Extremely important for Section 156(3).
Application under Section 156(3) should ordinarily be
supported by an affidavit and the Magistrate must apply judicial mind.
3. Lalita Kumari
(2014) 2 SCC 1
Mandatory registration where cognizable offence is
disclosed.
Practical sequence
Police Station
? written complaint
?
refusal/non-registration
? SP/DCP
? if still no
action
? Magistrate
under 156(3) CrPC / 175(3) BNSS
? alternatively,
depending on facts, complaint case under Section 200 CrPC / Section
223 BNSS.
V.
SECOND ROUTE — PRIVATE COMPLAINT
Old:
Section 200 CrPC
New:
Section 223 BNSS
The Magistrate examines the complainant and witnesses.
Then:
?
dismissal, or
?
issuance of process, or
?
inquiry/investigation as legally permissible.
Important cases
Pepsi Foods Ltd. v. Special Judicial Magistrate,
(1998) 5 SCC 749
Issuance of process is a serious matter; Magistrate
must apply judicial mind.
Maksud Saiyed v. State of Gujarat, (2008) 5 SCC 668
Application of mind is required while issuing process.
Mehmood Ul Rehman v. Khazir Mohammad Tunda, (2015)
12 SCC 420
Cognizance and issuance of process require judicial
application of mind.
VI.
FIR — WHAT SHOULD THE DEFENCE LAWYER IMMEDIATELY EXAMINE?
On receiving an FIR, prepare a one-page FIR audit.
1. Date and time of occurrence
Compare:
?
date of FIR;
?
delay;
?
explanation of delay;
?
medical record;
?
DD/GD entry;
?
112 call;
?
CCTV;
?
electronic communications.
2. Territorial jurisdiction
Ask:
?
Where did offence occur?
?
Is part of cause of action within jurisdiction?
?
Was Zero FIR possible?
?
Was FIR subsequently transferred?
3. Ingredients of offence
Don't merely look at section numbers.
Ask:
Does the factual narrative satisfy every ingredient
of the alleged offence?
4. Specific role
Especially in cases involving:
?
multiple accused;
?
family members;
?
company directors;
?
public servants;
?
conspiracy;
?
unlawful assembly.
5. Omissions and contradictions
Compare FIR with:
?
Section 161/180 statements;
?
Section 164/183 statement;
?
medical report;
?
seizure memo;
?
site plan;
?
CCTV;
?
call records;
?
charge-sheet.
6. Mala fide
Look for:
?
civil dispute;
?
property dispute;
?
matrimonial dispute;
?
commercial dispute;
?
counterblast;
?
political rivalry;
?
recovery pressure;
?
previous litigation.
VII.
MULTIPLE FIRs
A fundamental case:
T.T. Antony v. State of Kerala
(2001) 6 SCC 181
General principle:
A second FIR concerning the same
occurrence/transaction is ordinarily impermissible.
But the law subsequently developed around:
?
counter-cases;
?
different transactions;
?
larger conspiracy;
?
continuing investigation;
?
separate offences discovered during
investigation.
Later important authority
Amitbhai Anilchandra Shah v. CBI
(2013) 6 SCC 348
The concept of “same transaction” is crucial.
VIII.
QUASHING THE FIR — HIGH COURT
This is one of the most important criminal remedies.
Old:
Section 482 CrPC
New:
Section 528 BNSS
The NCRB comparative table expressly maps Section
528 BNSS to Section 482 CrPC.
Also relevant:
Article 226 Constitution
Therefore, in appropriate cases:
Article 226 + Section 528 BNSS
may be invoked before the High Court.
IX.
THE BHajan Lal TEST
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335
The classic seven categories where quashing may be
justified.
The most useful categories include situations where:
- allegations
do not constitute an offence;
- allegations do not
disclose a cognizable offence;
- allegations are
absurd/inherently improbable;
- legal bar exists;
- proceeding is manifestly
attended with mala fide;
- proceeding
is maliciously instituted for an ulterior purpose.
This remains one of the principal defence tools.







